VOTE NO on Initiative 1183

We are proponents of privatizing the WA State liquor business, and have voted yes on previous initiatives; however, 1183 is written by Costco to exclude small businesses from participating in the liberalization of these rules.  The grossest example of this is that stores have to be 10,000 square feet or larger to qualify for a liquor license, making it impossible for businesses oth…er than Costco, Safeway, Fred Meyer, etc to get a license.  Ultimately this will reduce competition and lower the offering in the marketplace for consumers.  We urge you to vote NO as there’s a better way to accomplish privatization. We are in full agreement with how fellow wine business McCarthy and Schiering states the case:

VOTE NO on 1183

By Dan | Published: August 5, 2010

Initiative 1183 would permit Costco, grocery stores, and other large volume discount retailers to sell liquor, but would prevent small, independent retailers like McCarthy and Schiering from selling select armagnac, calvados, single malt scotch, bourbon and specialty spirits from domestic distillers. To qualify for a liquor license under 1183, you must have a retail space of 10,000 square feet or more, unless you live in an area of the state where stores of that size do not exist. Our shops are about 1500 square feet each. Large grocery stores will be able to shout even louder “Buy your wine AND liquor with us, skip the extra stop!” But you will probably not be pleased with the selection. Existing generic wine offerings at grocery and big box stores are representative of what your liquor and spirits selections will be like if 1183 passes, with no opportunity for small independent retailers like us to offer you alternative selections!

If you enjoy special ordering wines a few bottles at a time from McCarthy & Schiering (wines that we do not normally stock), that service will cost you more in the future if 1183 passes, as our suppliers will raise the cost to us when we order in less than case quantities. This is the way it’s done in California with similar “volume discounting.” Your selection will decrease, and your price will increase, except on those generic offerings from the big box stores, or those wines we choose to purchase in 5 or 10 case quantities. Wines that we stock in 3 to 6 bottle quantities will certainly cost you more. Good luck finding them at Costco or Safeway!

We’re strong proponents of getting the state out of the liquor business — just not the way Costco wants to achieve it. Initiative 1183 is $22 million worth of Costco trying to impose its will, dominate the wine and liquor business in Washington, and further marginalize small independent retailers.  Let’s wait until there is a proposal that is fair to all the citizens and businesses in the state!

We urge you to VOTE NO on 1183!

Dan McCarthy and Jay Schiering


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s